Case Study >> Private Equity – Lower Middle Market >> Human Capital Operating Partner
Chief Human Capital Officer / Human Capital Operating Partner
Case Study >> Private Equity – Lower Middle Market >> Human Capital Operating Partner
Chief Human Capital Officer / Human Capital Operating Partner
Company
Confidential
Company Size
USD $3B AUM
Job Title
Chief Human Capital Officer / Human Capital Operating Partner (first strategic talent leader, covering the fund and its portfolio)
Industry
Private Equity – Lower Middle Market
Location
United States (remote-friendly, with regular travel)
The Client
This lower middle market private equity firm manages approximately $3 billion in assets and employs 30-40 people, and it invests across industrial and business services sectors. After a strong run of performance and a successful fundraise, the firm planned to grow both its own team and its portfolio, which was expected to more than double over the next few years; talent became a strategic priority.
The Ideal Candidate Profile
The firm needed a strategic senior leader to design and stand up the human capital function for both the fund and its portfolio companies. The role was broad and included a range of elements that are not commonly wrapped up all in one person. At a high level, the role would encompass:
- Talent acquisition strategy: the framework for how portfolio companies go to market for talent, including scorecards, assessment processes, and a network of trusted search partners. The person sets the approach and manages those relationships rather than running searches day to day.
- Organizational assessment and design: evaluating leadership team structures during due diligence and across current holdings. This includes identifying where problems stem from missing or poorly built teams rather than individual talent, and where growth and efficiency are held back by bottlenecks in the leadership team. The person then redesigns the structure and builds the right organization.
- Leadership development and succession: identifying who is fit for purpose, who needs support, and where the team needs to change or be coached and elevated.
- Cultural fit: a thick-skinned, high-energy collaborator who can execute independently, make decisions and avoid getting caught in the details. The firm moves quickly, is highly entrepreneurial, and expects results.
The Challenges
The firm had tried once before – it brought on a talent acquisition specialist to fill open roles, and the hire did not work out. That experience showed that the real need was broader than simply filling roles one by one.
Several challenges followed:
- An evolving mandate. Internal leaders had different views of what the role should be. Part of the work was helping the firm turn a general need for a “head of talent” into a defined mandate.
- A thin candidate pool. This market is generally considered to be only about 200 to 250 people in true human capital operating roles; they vary widely in background, and many are tied to their current firms by carry. More importantly, only a subset of those have experience across all three pillars we were targeting (Talent, Organizational Assessment/Design, Leadership Development).
- Strategy first, with some execution. The firm didn’t want someone running searches day-to-day or stuck in the weeds. They needed a framework builder with a strategic mindset who could build a scalable function. As a small firm, though, this person would also need to step in at times and execute hands-on.
- Compensation. The client was open to focusing first on the strongest talent and not being limited by compensation parameters. However, as a smaller fund of around $3B AUM, it would be challenging to hire away talent from much larger firms that were paying very high compensation.
Our Approach
Spire Search Partners has worked in portfolio operations for the past 15 years, building a deep presence. We make it our business to connect with and get to know the human capital and portfolio talent professionals on those teams, because they know best what’s happening in the world of PortCo talent. That gives us an excellent network to start with. From there, it’s about defining the mandate, getting agreement across the hiring managers, and running a proven process.
Defining the Mandate & The Opportunity
We worked with the firm’s leaders to sharpen what the role should own and what should come first, so the search could target a defined profile. We also built a clear picture of the opportunity, the backgrounds most likely to fit, and what the hiring team should and shouldn’t expect from the market.
Strategic Market Mapping
We connected with over 100 professionals in the space, grew our target pool by 10% through targeted referrals, and held in-depth conversations with more than 75 human capital operating executives, talent partners, chief talent officers, and portfolio company CHROs, mostly at middle-market firms. We looked past titles to understand each person’s actual scope, since the same title covers different seats at different firms.
We aim to cover as close to 100% of the market as possible in every search, and to leave no stone unturned.
Rigorous Assessment Framework
Assessment starts with the first call, where we look for evidence of the key competencies we’re seeking. We ask the right questions and dig down when necessary, so we understand a candidate’s experience without making assumptions. Using our scorecard, we structure these conversations to build that understanding quickly without cutting promising talent too soon. As with most hires, culture and personality fit are vital. When those are well aligned, it makes sense to relax how tightly we hold to parameters, especially on competencies that can be learned or developed.
Dynamic Re-steering
Weekly update conversations are the key to keeping the process moving forward and getting closer to a solution more quickly. These conversations refine our search strategy, share market insights, exchange candidate feedback, and dynamically adapt to evolving needs. This iterative process keeps the search on track as needs evolve.
Market Intelligence
We shared what we were hearing with the firm throughout, including how other funds scope the role, how compensation and carry affect candidate decisions, and where the real candidate pool sits.
The Outcome: A Perfect Match
After a thorough search and assessment of 75 individuals, we presented six highly qualified candidates. Three moved forward to meet the founders and the executive leadership team (ELT), and the firm ultimately selected an exceptional executive who exceeded their expectations on cultural and personality fit.
Spire Search Partners completed this complex search within twelve weeks, demonstrating our ability to deliver top-tier talent even in niche markets. The placement helped the firm accelerate its value creation strategy and strengthen its position in the lower middle-market private equity landscape.
Along the way, the firm gained a clearer view of the role, the market, and the competition for these candidates, which helped it make decisions with a full picture.
It All Starts With a Consultation!
For inquiries please contact: